Jamie5136,
Apparently your attorneys have determined that the person is non-exempt (most paralegals are) and that she worked, what, 3,000 hours of unpaid overtime?
Do you have any records that might refute that number?
For example:
Computer login data
Building entry security entries or
Security video
Also, you say she never worked OT; do you mean she never worked more than 40 hours in a week?
Just some thoughts; not legal advice.
Best wishes,
Steve
missmmc